Roundup · Aug 16, 2026

Best Chew Toys for Power Chewers

Every toy in this roundup was marketed as tough. We handed each one to Moose — 60 pounds of professional skepticism — and counted the days.

These are the survivors, ranked. Days quoted are real days from our test log, not manufacturer promises.

KONG Classic red rubber chew toy, placeholder test photo
Best Overall

1. KONG Classic

34 days and undefeated. The only toy that made our tester quit first.

Benebone Wishbone nylon chew after three weeks of testing, placeholder test photo
Best Nylon Chew

2. Benebone Wishbone

Three weeks of daily service. Loses slowly, safely, and with bacon.

Nylabone Power Chew bone with heavy wear marks, placeholder test photo
Best Budget Option

3. Nylabone Power Chew

Nine days against Moose — but a fine, cheaper pick for moderate chewers.